Labor’s Immigration Scam

The Macrobusiness piece by Leith van Onselen (18 November 2026, linked below), is a short critique that leans on columnist Judith Sloan's assessment in The Australian. It argues that the Albanese government's immigration "reset" is mostly spin: it largely locks in the May budget's net overseas migration (NOM) forecasts rather than delivering meaningful additional cuts.

Sloan describes the measures as "relatively inconsequential" and as merely confirming budget NOM numbers that remain "high by historical standards." The piece concludes the government has little real intent to reduce the intake below those levels; if the forecasts are missed, so be it. The response has been visa-integrity steps aimed at stopping overshoots, not a structural reduction in the planning numbers themselves.

Latest ABS reading: NOM of about 292,100 in the year to March 2026 (down sharply from the post-COVID peak above 500,000 but still elevated versus the pre-pandemic decade).

Budget/Labor targets the government says its September 2026 package is designed to meet: 245,000 in 2026–27 and 225,000 in 2027–28 (and beyond).

Main levers announced/implemented: tighter rules on international students bringing family members as secondary applicants; caps and a ballot system for second- and third-year Working Holiday Maker extensions; "no further stay" conditions on many visitor visas to limit onshore hopping; priority processing for skilled applicants in construction, health, teaching, agriculture and similar sectors; stronger compliance on overstayers; and related integrity changes.

Permanent migration planning levels have stayed around the 185,000 mark with a skilled-heavy split; a large share of permanent places go to people already onshore.

Macrobusiness has long argued that high NOM has worsened housing shortages, congestion and pressure on wages/services, and that Labor has repeatedly overshot earlier forecasts while downplaying the scale. The 225–245k targets are lower than the recent surge but still above the longer-run average of the 2010s for many years. Critics (including Sloan) treat them as a political floor rather than a genuine tightening relative to housing supply and infrastructure capacity.

By contrast, the Coalition has proposed cutting NOM to 100,000 for two years (then rising toward 160,000), with large reductions in temporary visa stocks, graduate visas and the humanitarian intake; if one is foolish enough to trust them! One Nation has gone further still. Labor's package is therefore the mildest of the major published plans and is framed by the government as restoring "order and integrity" while still supporting growth and skills needs. It is a sham.

Whether 225–245k constitutes a real reset or continued high intake depends on the baseline used (post-COVID peak vs pre-2010s average vs housing completions). The Sloan/Macrobusiness view is that the government is mainly managing the optics of the existing budget forecasts rather than setting a substantially lower trajectory. Typical Labor Party deception.

https://www.macrobusiness.com.au/2026/11/labors-immigration-reset-is-spin-over-substance/