This problem is seen most clearly in the US, but its heart lies in every Western country, including Australia. Nick Freitas (see link below for video), is right about the direction and probably right about the destination, and the most interesting thing about his warning is that the crisis he describes is not really a constitutional one. He says on Making the Argument: he cannot find a single elected Democrat who would organise a country he'd want to live in, he no longer believes he's talking to people who merely disagree about tax rates, and he thinks we are moving quickly toward a high-level constitutional crisis that will be "increasingly difficult to resolve peacefully." Kevin Slack, his guest, agrees and goes further: a country needs "certain rules to the game that everybody respects," and Americans no longer respect the same rules. That is the sentence that matters. Everything else is commentary.
The trigger Freitas names is James Carville's shopping list: statehood for D.C., statehood for Puerto Rico, four more justices on the Supreme Court. He's right that this isn't a policy programme but a constitutional coup conducted through procedural niceties: add four reliable votes and the document becomes whatever five people say it is. But notice what that admission concedes. If a bare legislative majority can restructure the referee and thereby rewrite the rules, then the rules were never load-bearing in the first place. A constitution that survives only because the other side lacks the votes is not a constitution; it's a temporary correlation of power with a nice preamble. Freitas knows this, which is why he asks the question he asks: does the current construction provide the means to fight this, or do we need extraconstitutional measures to protect the republic? That question has an answer, and the answer is uncomfortable, the means exist, they were always there, and they are the reason nobody wants to use them.
But the deeper crisis, and the one Slack circles without quite naming, is not legal. It is that the US has undergone a complete moral and epistemological break, and a constitutional order cannot arbitrate a dispute between two peoples who no longer share either a moral ontology or a method for establishing what is true.
Start with the moral break. The document was written for people who disagreed about interests inside a shared frame; tariffs, debt assumption, the scope of federal power, because interests can be split, traded, and compromised. What we have now is not an interest conflict. One coalition's foundational moral premise is that the country is a racist colonial evil power whose institutions are instruments of group domination; the other's is that the country is a flawed but fundamentally good inheritance worth preserving. Slack reads from an early-1970s National Education Association document asserting that all white individuals are racist whether or not they hold a single racist thought, because they receive benefits distributed by a racist society. He's right that this divides the citizenry, but he understates it. That proposition is not a policy position that can be negotiated down. It is a claim about the moral status of persons, and once half the country's institutions teach it and the other half rejects it, every subsequent dispute, school curricula, policing, hiring, speech, history, becomes a dispute about whether the other side's citizens are morally legitimate participants at all. You cannot compromise with someone whose existence you experience as an injustice. Compromise, in that frame, is complicity.
Then the epistemological break, which is worse because it forecloses the possibility of ever settling the first. A constitution is a machine for resolving disputes by agreed procedures applied to agreed facts. It presumes that when two parties disagree, there is some shared tribunal, courts, elections, a common record, whose verdict both will accept even in defeat. That presumption died somewhere in the last decade, and it did not die of natural causes. It was killed by institutions that discovered they could declare the questions closed. The category of "misinformation" was the murder weapon: a word that does not mean false, but means not permitted, applied by the same organisations that had been caught being wrong about the things they were policing. Once the fact-checkers are a partisan actor, there is no arbiter of fact left, and a society without an arbiter of fact cannot have a constitutional crisis in the classical sense. It can only have a permanent legitimacy war in which every election is stolen, every court ruling is partisan, and every official finding is propaganda. Both sides now believe this. One of them is substantially correct.
Which is why the "extraconstitutional measures" question has to be answered honestly rather than decorously. The American tradition has resolved genuine constitutional impasses three ways: judicial retreat, a decisive electoral realignment, or force. 1876 was resolved by a corrupt bargain that bought eighty years of segregation. 1860 was resolved at Shiloh. The system does not have a fourth gear, and the reason Freitas's warning lands is that everyone can feel the gearbox grinding. But the answer to "the referee has been captured" is not to storm the field. It is to stop pretending the referee is neutral, build institutions that don't require his blessing, and make the other side's capture of the referee irrelevant by routing around it: federalism, school choice, homeschooling, state-level enforcement, jury nullification, exit. The Second Amendment is the backstop that makes the rest of it possible, and it is precisely because it exists that the worst outcomes remain unlikely. A population that can't be disarmed is a population that doesn't have to shoot.
Slack's prescriptions, return to the older constitutional understanding, change education, impose a moratorium on legal immigration, are the right instincts in the wrong order. You cannot restore a constitutional understanding in a population that has been taught for two generations that the Constitution is a fraud, and you cannot change education while the teachers' unions own the machinery and the credentialing system owns the exits. What you can do is what's already happening: build the parallel structures, starve the captured ones, and let the ideological monoculture price itself out of relevance. That is slower than a march and less satisfying than a slogan, and it is the only path that doesn't end with Americans shooting Americans over a document neither side has read.
The bleak truth is that Freitas is describing a real thing and mislabelling it. It isn't the Constitution that's failing. It's the shared moral premise and the shared epistemology that made a constitution possible. Those cannot be legislated back into existence, and no court can rule them into being. They have to be rebuilt person by person, family by family, school by school, in a country where the institutions that should be doing the rebuilding are the ones that tore them down. That is a generational project, not an election. The people who think the next election fixes it are the same people who thought the last one would.
https://www.theblaze.com/shows/making-the-argument-with-nick-freitas/increasingly-difficult-to-resolve-peacefully-nick-freitas-warns-of-a-coming-constitutional-crisis