Australia has an extraordinary economic problem. Governments complain about labour shortages, employers struggle to recruit experienced workers, businesses demand additional immigration to fill vacancies, and politicians express concern about the nation's declining productivity. Yet at the same time, the Commonwealth maintains a pension system that financially penalises many older Australians who wish to continue working. These people possess decades of accumulated knowledge, practical skills and professional experience. Many remain physically and intellectually capable of making substantial contributions to society. But when they attempt to supplement their retirement incomes through employment, the government reduces their pensions. It is difficult to imagine a more counterproductive arrangement.
Leith van Onselen, writing in Macrobusiness on November 2, 2026, argues that Australia should abolish the Age Pension income test on employment earnings, allowing older Australians to work without losing their pension entitlements. The proposal has attracted growing support from seniors' organisations, employers and industry representatives. Its appeal is straightforward. Instead of discouraging productive activity among older Australians, the government should encourage those who wish to work to remain economically active.
The current arrangements create an unnecessary conflict between employment and retirement security. Under the Age Pension income test, a single pensioner can ordinarily receive $226 per fortnight in assessable income before the pension begins to decline. Beyond that threshold, the pension is generally reduced by 50 cents for each additional dollar of assessable income. The Work Bonus allows eligible pensioners to exclude the first $300 per fortnight of income from employment or qualifying self-employment, meaning that a single pensioner with no other assessable income can generally earn $526 per fortnight before the pension begins to fall.
The Work Bonus also allows unused amounts to accumulate, subject to a maximum balance of $11,800. These provisions are improvements upon earlier arrangements, but they remain unnecessarily complicated. Pensioners must understand the interaction between income thresholds, employment earnings, accumulated Work Bonus balances and other financial circumstances. The resulting system can discourage additional work precisely when the economy would benefit from it.
Consider a pensioner who has spent forty years working as a nurse, teacher, electrician, mechanic or agricultural specialist. Such a person may be perfectly capable of working two or three days each week. An employer might welcome the assistance, particularly where younger workers are difficult to recruit. Yet the pensioner must calculate how additional earnings will affect pension payments, taxation and other financial arrangements.
The rational response may be to decline additional shifts or restrict working hours. The economy loses productive labour, employers lose access to experience, and the pensioner loses an opportunity to improve financial security.
The problem becomes especially serious when older Australians have limited retirement savings. Not everyone retires with a substantial superannuation balance and a mortgage-free home. Many older people have experienced interrupted employment, divorce, illness, family responsibilities or periods of low income. Some continue paying rent or servicing mortgages well beyond pension age.
For these Australians, part-time employment can make the difference between financial hardship and a reasonable standard of living. It can provide money for household repairs, medical expenses, transport and ordinary social participation. Yet the existing pension arrangements reduce the financial reward from undertaking that work.
An ABC News report published on October 27, 2026, examined the experience of Peter Gibney, a 71-year-old supermarket worker in Queensland. Gibney and his wife both receive part Age Pensions and continue working because they have financial obligations, including a mortgage. He enjoys his employment and values the opportunity to remain active, but believes the pension system penalises his willingness to work.
His circumstances illustrate a broader problem. Retirement is no longer a single, clearly defined event at which every Australian permanently withdraws from paid employment. Many people prefer a gradual transition, reducing their working hours while remaining professionally and socially engaged.
Others discover that retirement does not suit them. They miss the routine, companionship and sense of achievement associated with employment. Some return to work because they need additional income, while others simply enjoy being productive. There is no sensible reason for government policy to discourage these choices.
The Council on the Ageing Australia has called for simplification of the pension rules. The Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry has proposed doubling the Work Bonus to $600 per fortnight, while National Seniors Australia advocates exempting employment income from the Age Pension income test altogether.
The National Seniors proposal is particularly attractive because it would remove the financial penalty rather than merely increase the threshold at which the penalty begins.
The organisation has also commissioned economic modelling from Deloitte. According to National Seniors, the modelling suggests that exempting employment income from the pension income test could become fiscally neutral if approximately 8.3 per cent of pensioners worked or increased their existing employment.
That is a modelling result rather than a guaranteed outcome. The actual fiscal consequences would depend upon how many pensioners changed their behaviour, how much additional income they earned and how much additional tax revenue the government collected. Nevertheless, it demonstrates that the proposal deserves serious consideration rather than immediate dismissal as an unaffordable welfare expansion.
There is a basic economic principle involved. When the government reduces the financial return from productive activity, it discourages some of that activity. The Age Pension income test operates as an additional effective marginal tax on employment earnings.
For a pensioner whose payment is being reduced by 50 cents for each additional dollar of assessable income, the financial reward from working can be substantially diminished. Ordinary income tax may further reduce the amount retained. The combined effect can make additional shifts considerably less attractive than they initially appear. This is especially counterproductive when Australia faces persistent labour shortages in essential industries.
Aged care is an obvious example. Older Australians who have worked as nurses, carers, administrators and allied health professionals possess valuable experience. Some may no longer wish to undertake full-time employment or physically demanding shifts, but could contribute through part-time duties, mentoring, training or less demanding roles.
The same applies to education. Retired teachers can assist schools experiencing staffing difficulties, provide tutoring or support younger teachers. Their accumulated knowledge of classroom management and educational practice may be particularly valuable.
Agriculture also offers opportunities for older workers. Experienced farmers, mechanics, machinery operators and agricultural specialists possess practical skills that cannot always be replaced by formal qualifications. Seasonal and part-time employment could allow them to contribute without accepting the demands of full-time work.
Small businesses would benefit as well. Older Australians may be willing to undertake bookkeeping, customer service, consulting, administration or occasional technical work. Such arrangements can provide employers with experienced assistance without requiring permanent full-time positions.
Professional and intellectual occupations are especially suitable for continued employment beyond conventional retirement age. Writing, research, teaching, consulting and many forms of analysis depend heavily upon accumulated knowledge and judgment. Physical ageing does not automatically eliminate these capacities. Indeed, experience can become more valuable with age in occupations where understanding complex problems matters more than physical speed.
This does not mean that every older person should continue working. Retirement remains a legitimate and often necessary choice. Some Australians have spent decades in physically demanding occupations and deserve the opportunity to rest. Others experience disabilities, chronic illnesses or family responsibilities that make employment difficult or impossible.
The proposal is not to compel pensioners to work, but to remove unnecessary financial penalties from those who voluntarily choose to do so. An ageing society should recognise differences in individual circumstances rather than impose a rigid assumption that everyone becomes economically unproductive at a particular birthday.
Australia's population is ageing, and the proportion of older citizens is expected to increase over coming decades. This creates challenges for healthcare, aged care, taxation and public expenditure. But it also creates opportunities if more older Australians remain economically active.
The traditional distinction between a working population and a retired population becomes increasingly inadequate when many people remain capable of contributing well beyond 67.
According to the Council on the Ageing's State of the Older Nation research, approximately 15 per cent of Australians aged over 67 continue working, compared with 11 per cent in 2021. Almost one-quarter of older Australians are not opposed to returning to employment in some capacity. These figures suggest a substantial pool of potential labour that existing policies may be failing to utilise.
The economic benefits would extend beyond the additional hours worked. Older employees can provide mentoring, institutional knowledge and practical judgment. They can help younger workers develop skills and avoid mistakes. Businesses may become more productive when experienced and inexperienced employees work together.
There is also a possible benefit for public finances. Older workers earning additional income would generally pay income tax according to the ordinary rules. Increased employment could strengthen economic output and consumer spending. Some pensioners might accumulate additional savings, improving their financial resilience.
The government would initially forgo some savings currently achieved by reducing pension payments to working pensioners. But those costs must be weighed against the additional economic activity and tax revenue generated by greater workforce participation. A reform should be judged by its net consequences, not simply by the immediate expenditure recorded in the social services budget.
There is also a strong argument concerning immigration policy. Australia has increasingly relied upon immigration to address labour shortages and support economic growth. Skilled immigration can make valuable contributions, but rapid population growth also increases demand for housing, transport, healthcare and other infrastructure.
Encouraging older Australians to remain in employment could reduce some recruitment pressures without creating the same immediate additional demand for housing and public services associated with population growth.
It would be unrealistic to suggest that older workers could replace every skilled migrant or meet every labour shortage. Some industries require specialised qualifications, geographic mobility or physically demanding work that not every pensioner can provide.
Nevertheless, it makes little economic sense to overlook an existing pool of experienced Australian workers while arguing that labour shortages can only be resolved through additional immigration. A sensible government would examine every available source of productive capacity, including older Australians who wish to work.
The policy also has implications for personal wellbeing. Employment is not merely a means of earning money. For many people it provides structure, social interaction, intellectual stimulation and a sense of purpose. The sudden disappearance of these elements following retirement can be difficult, particularly for individuals whose identities have been closely connected to their occupations.
Research on ageing and employment suggests that suitable work can support social participation and wellbeing, although the benefits depend upon working conditions, personal preferences and health. Poorly paid, stressful or physically inappropriate employment may produce the opposite result.
The objective should therefore be voluntary, flexible and meaningful participation rather than an expectation that everyone must remain employed indefinitely.
Part-time work may be particularly beneficial. Two or three days of employment each week can provide social contact and additional income while leaving sufficient time for family, recreation, exercise and other interests. Such arrangements may also reduce pressure upon employers by allowing experienced staff to remain available without committing to full-time schedules.
There is a philosophical issue here concerning society's treatment of older people. Modern economic culture often assumes that human value is closely associated with youth, speed and technological adaptability. Older workers may be regarded as expensive, inflexible or incapable of learning new skills.
These stereotypes are frequently unjustified. Individual differences are substantial, and chronological age is an imperfect measure of competence.
An experienced worker who remains capable, motivated and productive should not be excluded simply because of age. Nor should the state discourage such employment through an unnecessarily punitive pension system.
There is something particularly contradictory about governments encouraging active ageing while financially penalising some of the very activities that make active ageing possible.
Politicians frequently celebrate the importance of keeping older Australians socially connected, mentally stimulated and physically active. Yet the pension income test can discourage the employment that provides these benefits.
The contradiction becomes more obvious when considered from the perspective of personal independence. An older Australian who earns additional income is less dependent upon family assistance and better able to meet unexpected expenses. Financial independence can support dignity and personal choice. It may allow people to maintain their homes, participate in community activities and avoid unnecessary hardship. Why should public policy discourage this outcome?
There is also a question of fairness. Many pensioners have spent decades paying income tax, contributing to public institutions and supporting earlier generations of retirees. They may reasonably regard the Age Pension as part of the social arrangements established during their working lives.
Australia's Age Pension is legally a means-tested payment rather than an individual savings account or an unconditional return of taxes previously paid. Nevertheless, there is a legitimate political argument that citizens who have contributed throughout their lives should not face excessive financial penalties merely because they continue working after reaching pension age.
New Zealand offers an alternative approach. Its NZ Super system is generally available to eligible older residents without an income or assets test, although residency and other conditions apply. Employment earnings do not ordinarily reduce the payment. Australia need not adopt the entire New Zealand model to recognise the advantages of allowing pensioners to retain more of their earnings.
A targeted reform exempting genuine employment and active self-employment income from the Age Pension income test would preserve other elements of Australia's means-testing arrangements while encouraging workforce participation. Such a distinction would also address a legitimate concern about wealthy retirees receiving public payments regardless of their overall financial position.
Under a targeted approach, the existing assets test and assessment of non-employment income could remain. The reform would focus upon removing the disincentive to productive labour.
There would still be difficult questions about the treatment of business income, company structures and income arrangements designed primarily to obtain pension advantages. These matters would require clear legislative definitions and appropriate safeguards. But administrative complexity should not become an excuse for avoiding worthwhile reform.
Australia already operates sophisticated taxation and social security systems. It should be possible to distinguish genuine earnings from employment and active business activity from passive investment income.
Indeed, the existing Work Bonus already makes such distinctions. Reform would simplify the financial consequences of working rather than introduce an entirely unfamiliar concept.
The federal government should therefore undertake a serious assessment of the National Seniors proposal, including independent modelling of employment responses, fiscal costs and the likely effects upon different income groups.
The reform could be introduced gradually if necessary, with clear evaluation of its effects upon workforce participation and government revenue. What should not continue is the assumption that the present system is economically sensible simply because it has existed for many years.
Australia faces serious structural challenges, including weak productivity growth, housing pressures, skills shortages and an ageing population. These problems cannot be resolved through one policy change. But encouraging experienced Australians to remain economically active is among the more straightforward reforms available. The alternative is to continue discouraging willing workers while simultaneously complaining that the economy lacks sufficient labour. That is hardly a convincing strategy for national prosperity.
There is a broader lesson concerning the role of government. Public policy should encourage useful activity, personal independence and voluntary contribution. It should not create unnecessary obstacles to people who wish to support themselves and serve their communities.
Older Australians are not simply recipients of government expenditure. They are citizens with accumulated knowledge, experience and abilities that can remain valuable for many years. A society that treats retirement age as the beginning of compulsory economic irrelevance wastes human potential.
The economic case for reform is therefore accompanied by a moral one. People should be free to continue contributing according to their capacities and preferences, without facing unnecessary financial punishment.
The greatest benefit may ultimately be cultural. Allowing pensioners to work without losing benefits would challenge the assumption that older age necessarily means withdrawal from productive life. It would recognise that human abilities develop differently and that meaningful work can continue long after conventional retirement age.
Some Australians will prefer complete retirement. Others will choose occasional work, consulting, volunteering or part-time employment. A smaller number may wish to continue full-time careers. Public policy should accommodate these differences rather than impose artificial financial barriers. Australia cannot afford to waste the experience of its older citizens while facing persistent economic and demographic pressures.
The solution is straightforward. Let pensioners who wish to work retain their earnings without reducing their Age Pension on account of that work, while preserving appropriate safeguards concerning assets and other income.
https://www.macrobusiness.com.au/2026/11/calls-grow-to-let-pensioners-work-without-losing-benefits/
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/business-leaders-nationals-party-veterans-join-coalition-and-one-nation-call-for-pensioners-to-work-more-without-being-penalised/news-story/cb29b99d0e56081c63d52a5c23dca490